[Well this game out of nowhere. Also, Papyrus is so Papyrus that he makes it immediately obvious that this isn't actually a casual inquiry. Hell, even thinking this is something that could be asked casually seems beyond even Papyrus's means.

Part of him wants to sidestep the conversation entirely, but the other swallows and attempts to stand his ground.]

Just... feeling like I'd done something before. Or remembering it two different ways. I guess it got worse the more versions there were to remember.

[Now you explain why you're asking this private as hell question.]